Sisters Balance Motherhood and Ministry to Earn Master’s Degrees Together
Sisters Ashley Pickens Bauer and Emily Pickens Mitchell already shared a lot in common. Besides coming from the same family, each had a deep commitment to ministry, and each was raising a set of twins.
Their commonalities increased again recently when they shared a distinct accomplishment: completing their master's degrees in theology and biblical studies together.
Family History on the Hill
Both women had earned their undergraduate degrees at Trevecca, following in the footsteps of their father. They both felt led to pursue graduate education, although for different reasons.
Growing up in a pastor's family alongside her older sister, Mitchell was involved in ministry from an early age but felt God leading her toward the classroom. She earned her bachelor’s degree in math and education. Her professors taught her how to care for students well in a public school setting, where her ministry was a matter of loving students from all backgrounds and faiths.
After a few years of teaching, she sensed that God was calling her to something more.
“I just felt like God was telling me this was the time to dive into what ministry looks like for me as a teacher. I met a couple of other teachers in the program as well. We had a whole other perspective of theology and how that plays a part in our role in the classroom,” Mitchell said. “At the same time, I was pretty involved in ministry at my church leading a Sunday school class for young adults, so it really helped shape my heart for ministry.”
Bauer's path to graduate school began with a bachelor's degree in religion from Trevecca and the journey towards ordination. She loved the work but knew she needed additional preparation. She was also intrigued by the course list, which was unlike any she had seen before. Each class rigorously engaged theology with the realities of the 21st century.
“I had a few years under my belt with youth ministry and felt like there were things I still needed to learn in order to do ministry to the fullest of what I feel God is calling me to,” Bauer said.
She began her master’s after returning to work at Trevecca as a graduate enrollment counselor with her husband Jeremy, who serves as a resident director. Her sister had already begun the program. Many of the program's professors were the same ones who had deeply shaped her theology during her undergraduate years.
Changing Seasons and Deepening Theology
The sisters began their degrees during different semesters but overlapped on many of their classes. Each week, they would log on to live Zoom sessions with a cohort of pastors and others in ministry. Each class began with updates about life. Though separated by time zones, states and sometimes countries, Mitchell, Bauer and their classmates became a tight-knit group that supported and encouraged one another.
During her second semester, Mitchell found out she was expecting twins. Bauer already had a set of toddler twins of her own.
“It was so fun to start class and have Emily tell everybody that she was pregnant. Everyone was thrilled,” Bauer said.
Mitchell spent most of the program pregnant and gave birth to twin boys during the summer, leaving her with only two classes to finish. She decided to stick it out.
“Honestly, I feel like the professors were so great. Everybody who’s in school as an adult is going through something. Life doesn’t stop moving just because you go to grad school,” Mitchell said.
Some weeks, Mitchell appeared on camera with a baby while Bauer joined with a toddler or two. The sisters texted each other during Zoom sessions and caught each other up when one had to miss a class.
“It was so fun to see that much of our lives intertwined,” Ashley said. “School and having twins.”
The coursework shaped them as much as the program's flexibility supported them, marrying scripture, church history and the challenges facing the Church globally.
“The Theology of Hospitality class was the most impactful for me personally.There is a rebirth of theology of hospitality in the church and having an opportunity to dive in as deep as we did was so important,” Bauer said. “I would also say Theology of Race and Culture was world-shifting in a way that I'm so grateful for. I feel like it's something all pastors should have the opportunity to learn.”
For Mitchell, some of her most important learning came from a unique course called Theology of Place.
“I saw the theme of secularity played out with students in the classroom where I taught and even as a Sunday school teacher,” Mitchell said. “When I got to the Theology of Place class, everything clicked for me. I learned what it means for us to be part of God's story.”
At graduation, the sisters sat next to each other. Their names were called back-to-back as they crossed the stage with their families in the audience.
“I just remember this feeling of pride for myself, but also on behalf of my sister. Because I went through the program as a mom working a full-time job and so did she, we both did that together,” Bauer said. “It was such a fun opportunity for us to be able to enjoy that moment. Just the way our families got to come together for that was really special.”

